Home Foreign Born

Foreign Born

Are Foreign Children Entitled to Free Public Education?

Are Foreign Children Entitled to Free Public Education?

Are Foreign Children Entitled to Free Public Education?

Access to quality education is a fundamental right for every child, regardless of their nationality or residency status. Yet, millions of children worldwide are denied this right due to various reasons, including poverty, conflict, and discrimination. In recent years, the issue of whether foreign children should have access to free public education has become a subject of debate and controversy in many countries across the globe.

In this article, we will explore the eligibility of foreign children for free public education, the legal framework governing this right, the benefits of providing education to foreign children, and the challenges faced in ensuring access to education for all.

Understanding the Legal Framework

The right to education is enshrined in numerous international legal instruments, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Convention on the Rights of the Child, and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. These instruments emphasize the importance of access to quality education as essential to achieving social and economic development for individuals and society as a whole.

The Convention on the Rights of the Child, in particular, calls for the provision of education without discrimination of any kind, including based on a child’s nationality. The Convention further stipulates that education should be provided on the basis of equal opportunity, by whatever means, and without discrimination of any kind (Article 28).

Despite this legal framework, many countries have placed restrictions on access to free public education for foreign children, often citing concerns about limited resources, overcrowded classrooms, and the burden on taxpayers.

Eligibility for Free Public Education

In most countries, the eligibility of foreign children for free public education depends on their residency status. Children who are citizens or legal residents of a country are generally entitled to free public education, while those who are undocumented or legally residing in the country on a temporary basis may not have the same rights.

However, this is not always the case. In the United States, for example, the Supreme Court ruled in Plyler v. Doe (1982) that all children, regardless of their immigration status, have a right to access public education. The court found that denying education to undocumented children imposes a lifetime hardship on a discrete class of children not accountable for their disabling status.

Similarly, in Canada, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees the right to education to all individuals residing in the country, regardless of their immigration status.

Benefits of Providing Education to Foreign Children

Providing education to foreign children has numerous benefits, both for the individuals and society as a whole. Access to education has been shown to improve cognitive and social development, increase earning potential in adulthood, reduce poverty and inequality, and help create more cohesive communities.

For foreign children, education can provide a sense of stability and structure in what may be a turbulent and uncertain period of their lives. It can also be an important tool for social integration and cultural exchange, enabling them to learn about the culture and customs of their new home and to form relationships with their peers.

In addition to the individual benefits, providing education to foreign children can have a positive impact on society as a whole. Educated individuals are more likely to be active and engaged citizens, contributing to democratic processes and social progress. They are also more likely to be employed and to contribute to the economy, reducing the burden on social services and contributing to the tax base.

Challenges to Providing Education for All

Despite the legal framework and the potential benefits of providing education to foreign children, there are numerous challenges to ensuring access to education for all.

One of the primary challenges is the cost of providing education to an increasing number of students, particularly when resources are limited. Some countries have implemented policies to restrict access to education for foreign children, arguing that the cost of educating non-citizens places an undue burden on taxpayers.

Another challenge is the language barrier. Many foreign children may not speak the language of instruction, making it difficult for them to fully participate in the classroom and to understand the curriculum. This can be compounded by cultural differences and a lack of familiarity with the education system in their new country.

Additionally, social and cultural barriers can make it difficult for foreign children to integrate into the school community and to feel included in classroom activities and social events. Discrimination and xenophobia can also be significant barriers to accessing education and can lead to feelings of isolation and exclusion among foreign children.

Conclusion

Ensuring access to quality education for all children, regardless of their nationality or residency status, is a fundamental human right and a cornerstone of social and economic development. While legal frameworks exist to support this right, challenges remain in ensuring access to education for all, particularly in the face of limited resources, language barriers, and social and cultural barriers.

While it is important to recognize the challenges and limitations, it is equally important to continue to advocate for the right to education for all children and to work towards creating inclusive and welcoming education systems that support the needs of diverse student populations. Only then can we truly achieve the vision of a world where every child has access to quality education and the opportunity to reach their full potential.


Any child, whether being an American citizen, legal immigrant, or illegal immigrant has the right to a free public school education. This is a highly debated concept, since taxpayer money is used to fund the education of children who were allowed to enter the country in the first place, regardless of legal status. Arguments for and against this policy tend to lead to specific questions of whether or not children of illegal immigration, both foreign-born and domestically-born, should be entitled to an education in the United States.

As with most issues on the topic of illegal immigration, political opinions vary with regard to illegal immigrants
in public schools and which immigration laws should be enacted alongside these concerns. Currently, laws addressing illegal immigration permit all children to receive a public education.

A primary issue presented by presence of children of illegal immigration in the public school system is the underlying cost of their general education. In 2004, statistics showed that California spent about $7.7 billion per year to educate the total number of illegal immigrants in public schools–a figure that comprised 17% of the budget for the entire school system in California. California has a high rate of illegal immigration because of its close proximity to the Mexican border, and it was discovered that in the entire United States, it cost $28.4 billion in 2004 to educate the children of illegal immigrants in public schools.

Ultimately, presence of children of illegal immigration in the public school system, and the general expenses that surround them, creates a very expensive situation, in addition to causing a large degree of controversy. Since efforts are being made by Congress to allow children of illegal immigration to attend college, the tension has greatly escalated; some individuals think that offering a college education to the children of illegal immigrants provide undue incentives to immigrate illegally.

The presence of children of illegal immigration in the public school system continues to stir up debate. While the idea of paying taxes for legal immigrant children to become educated evokes tension, some take opposing views in considering that public dollars are spent educating children of illegal immigration. Despite a concerted effort to enact a counter-policy that these immigrant laws hold, children of illegal immigration are still permitted to partake in the American public school system.

Foreign Born Children and Health Care

Foreign Born Children and Health Care

Introduction

With an increasingly globalized world, the number of foreign-born individuals residing in the United States continues to grow each year. According to the Migration Policy Institute, 44.9 million immigrants live in the United States as of 2019, making up 13.7% of the total U.S. population. Among these immigrants, around 7.5 million are children, accounting for nearly 1 in 4 children living in the United States. When it comes to healthcare, these foreign-born children face unique challenges due to language barriers, cultural differences, and the lack of knowledge about the healthcare system in the United States.

In this article, we will explore the specific challenges that foreign-born children face when accessing healthcare in the United States. We will also look at current resources and initiatives aimed at improving healthcare access for these children.

Cultural Barriers

One of the more significant challenges for foreign-born children accessing healthcare is the cultural barriers they face. These barriers can include language differences, the lack of familiarity with U.S. healthcare systems, and the differing cultural attitudes toward healthcare.

Language Barriers

With over 350 languages spoken in the United States, language barriers can be difficult for foreign-born children to overcome, especially when it comes to healthcare. Children may not be able to accurately describe their symptoms or understand the language used by healthcare providers, leading to inaccurate diagnoses and treatments.

According to a 2015 survey by the Kaiser Family Foundation, nearly one-third of limited-English proficient (LEP) children and families reported having difficulty communicating with healthcare providers. Additionally, 42% of these children and families reported not receiving language assistance when needed, despite federal laws requiring healthcare providers to provide interpretation and translation services.

To overcome these language barriers, healthcare providers can utilize professional interpretation services and translated materials. Under the Affordable Care Act, healthcare providers are required to provide oral interpretation services for individuals with LEP, as well as translated written materials and notices.

Lack of Familiarity with U.S. Healthcare Systems

Foreign-born children may not be familiar with the healthcare system in the United States, including the types of services available and how to access them. This lack of knowledge can make it difficult for foreign-born children to access healthcare services, leading to delayed care and an increased risk of developing more severe health problems.

To overcome this issue, healthcare providers can aim to educate foreign-born families about the healthcare system in the United States. This can include providing them with information about the types of services available, how to access care, and what to expect during a medical visit. Additionally, healthcare providers can work to establish relationships with foreign-born communities to build trust and help families navigate the healthcare system more effectively.

Cultural Attitudes Toward Healthcare

Cultural attitudes toward healthcare can also be a barrier for foreign-born children accessing healthcare. Some cultures may view healthcare differently than in the United States, leading to differences in practices and beliefs.

For example, in some cultures, it is common to use traditional or home remedies to treat illnesses rather than seeking medical attention. Additionally, some cultures may prioritize preventative care over treatment, while others may feel that medical treatment is unnecessary unless symptoms are severe.

To overcome these cultural barriers, healthcare providers can work to understand and respect the cultural beliefs and attitudes of foreign-born families. Providers can also work to educate families about the importance of preventative care and the availability of medical treatments for various illnesses.

Healthcare Coverage

Another challenge that foreign-born children face when accessing healthcare in the United States is lack of healthcare coverage. While some foreign-born children may qualify for government-sponsored healthcare coverage, many may not be eligible due to immigration status or other factors.

For example, noncitizen immigrants who are not lawful permanent residents are often ineligible for most types of government-sponsored healthcare coverage, including Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP).

According to a 2019 report by the Kaiser Family Foundation, among uninsured children in the United States, approximately 45% were estimated to be LEP or Hispanic, and nearly 70% were estimated to be low-income.

To overcome these coverage barriers, healthcare providers can work to identify and connect uninsured foreign-born children with local resources that can provide healthcare coverage or financial assistance. Providers can also work to advocate for policies that expand healthcare coverage to all children, regardless of immigration status.

Access to Care

Even when foreign-born children have healthcare coverage, they may still face challenges accessing healthcare services. These access barriers can include transportation issues, lack of available healthcare providers in their communities, and long wait times for appointments.

Transportation Issues

Transportation issues can be challenging for foreign-born children and their families, particularly in rural or remote areas. Lack of access to transportation can limit their ability to receive preventative care or seek medical attention when they need it.

To overcome transportation barriers, healthcare providers can work with local transportation providers to offer discounted or free transportation services for medical appointments. Providers can also explore alternative methods of providing healthcare, such as telehealth services that can be accessed remotely.

Availability of Healthcare Providers

Foreign-born children may face challenges accessing healthcare services if there is a lack of available healthcare providers in their communities. This can be a particular issue in areas with a high population of foreign-born individuals, as there may not be enough healthcare providers who speak the language or are familiar with the cultural needs of these communities.

To overcome these provider shortages, healthcare providers can work to increase the number of providers who are trained to work with foreign-born children and families. Providers can also work to establish relationships with community organizations and advocates to identify and address the healthcare needs of foreign-born communities.

Long Wait Times

Long wait times for medical appointments can be a barrier for foreign-born children accessing healthcare. These long wait times can delay care and lead to severe health problems if left untreated.

To overcome long wait times, healthcare providers can work to implement scheduling policies that prioritize urgent medical needs for foreign-born children and families. Providers can also explore alternative methods of providing healthcare services, such as same-day appointments or walk-in services.

Conclusion

Foreign-born children face unique challenges when accessing healthcare in the United States, including cultural barriers, lack of healthcare coverage, and difficulty accessing care. To overcome these challenges, healthcare providers must work to address the specific needs of foreign-born children and their families, such as providing language assistance, educating families about the healthcare system in the United States, and identifying and addressing the healthcare needs of their communities.

By working to improve healthcare access for foreign-born children, healthcare providers can help improve the health outcomes for these vulnerable populations and promote greater health equity in the United States.


As a result of the United States facing financial crisis and suffering from a lack of accessible health care, a
large percentage of the American public disagree with an immigration policy that allows illegal immigrants to have access to subsidized health care. While illegal immigrants are not legally entitled to many of the forms of health care citizens can get, they sometimes rely heavily on state emergency Medicaid dollars–these funds are designated as part of government-sponsored health care program geared towards low-income households.

In cases of medical emergencies, hospitals cannot turn anyone away, regardless of financial or legal standing.
Yet, illegal residents are not entitled to anything beyond emergency health care unless they pay out of pocket for it. Many then choose to visit free public clinics for medical help, but these clinics are often understaffed and
overbooked.

Aside from California, Texas is the most popular state for illegal adult and child immigration, due mostly to its close proximity to the Mexican border. In Texas alone, it has been estimated that illegal immigrants, many of which are considered to be children of illegal immigration, cost hospitals roughly $1.3 billion in 2006–a number that has continued to grow.

Politicians are desperately trying to come to an agreement about the policies that should go into effect involving illegal adult and child immigration. Some are trying to cut the amount of money taxpayers have had to spend footing the often-large medical bills that are required for basic care of illegal immigrants. These same policymakers are trying to cut down the amount of money that the American public spends on the education of a child born to parents without citizenship.

Nationally, efforts to get health insurance for just a legal child immigrant from the State Children’s Health Insurance Program is still up in the air. Many argue that illegal immigrants adversely affect the number of American citizens without health insurance due to the increasing costs of adult and child immigrant
health care.

America has been facing a health care crisis for some time now, and even with health care on the national agenda, Americans are still struggling to get the care they need. The question of whether or not illegal immigrants, regardless of age, should be entitled to free health care is a notoriously controversial
issue.

The Nightmare of Deporting Foreign Children

The Nightmare of Deporting Foreign Children

The Nightmare of Deporting Foreign Children

Introduction

The United States of America is a country built on the foundation of immigrants. However, in recent years, the country has taken a turn towards a more defensive approach to immigration. This has resulted in a staggering increase in the number of children who are being deported from the country. These children are being sent back to their home countries, where they may face extreme hardships, including poverty, abuse, violence, and death. The deportation of foreign children is a nightmare that haunts the United States, causing irreparable damage to the lives of innocent children and their families.

Background

Deportation is the formal process of expelling individuals from a country. It is a legal process that is used when an individual has violated immigration or criminal laws. Currently, the United States is the home of over 44 million immigrants, and the number is increasing every year. According to a report by Migration Policy Institute, there were 11.3 million unauthorized immigrants residing in the United States in 2016. Out of these, an estimated 1.1 million were children, which accounted for approximately 10% of the total unauthorized immigrant population.

Deportation is a traumatic experience for anyone, let alone children who often have no control over their legal status. According to a report by the American Immigration Council, between 2003 and 2017, more than 200,000 parents of American-born children were deported. This means that the number of children who were separated from their parents due to deportation was equally high.

Deportation of foreign children can lead to severe and long-term negative impacts on their mental and emotional well-being. It is a life-altering experience that can leave children with irreparable scars.

Why Children are Deported

Children are being deported from the United States for a multitude of reasons. The most common reason is that they are undocumented. In other cases, they may have entered the country legally, but their visas have expired, or they may have committed a crime or violated immigration laws.

The United States immigration laws are complex; therefore, many children who are deported have had limited access to legal counsel or support services. This often means that they do not understand their rights or have the appropriate legal representation.

The Process of Deportation

The process of deportation is a complicated and lengthy one. A child may be arrested and detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials for violating immigration or criminal laws. Once they are detained, they are put in a holding cell, where they await their hearing.

During this time, they may experience severe psychological stress due to the uncertainty and isolation they face. They are often held in cramped and unhygienic conditions, putting them at risk of contracting infectious diseases.

The hearing can take months or sometimes even years to be scheduled, during which time the child remains in detention. The child has the right to legal counsel, but many cannot afford it, leaving them without adequate representation and further increasing their chances of being deported.

The child’s case is then heard by an immigration judge who decides whether the child should be deported or allowed to remain in the country. The judge’s decision can be appealed, but this process can be lengthy and expensive.

Economic Costs of Deporting Children

Deporting children can have severe economic repercussions. According to a report by the American Action Forum, the deportation of all 1.1 million undocumented children living in the United States would lead to a reduction in GDP by $329 billion in the next ten years. This would also lead to significant losses in tax revenue, as many of these children may grow up to become taxpayers. Deporting children would also result in economic hardships for their families, who may lose their only source of income.

Risks and Dangers of Deportation

Deporting children can have severe negative impacts on their physical and mental health. Children who are deported may be sent to countries where they have no support network, no access to healthcare, little food, and may not even speak the language.

Deported children are also at risk of violence and exploitation. A report by the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) states that children who are deported are vulnerable to trafficking, sexual exploitation, and abuse.

Additionally, deporting children can lead to long-term mental health issues such as anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

Government Action

The United States government has taken several actions to address the issue of deportation of foreign children. The Obama Administration issued a memorandum in 2011, outlining guidelines to be followed when deporting parents of American-born children. The guidelines instructed ICE officials to take into consideration the best interests of a child when making deportation decisions.

However, the current administration has taken a more aggressive stance on immigration, leading to a sharp increase in the number of children being deported. In 2018, the Trump administration implemented a zero-tolerance policy, which led to the separation of thousands of children from their parents at the border. The policy was condemned by the United Nations as a violation of children’s rights.

The Biden administration has taken several steps to address the issue of immigration and deportation of foreign children. In February 2021, President Biden signed an executive order to create a task force aimed at reunifying separated families. Additionally, the administration has introduced a bill, which proposes granting a pathway to citizenship for undocumented immigrants, including children.

Conclusion

Deportation of foreign children is a nightmare that has haunted the United States for years. It is a traumatic experience that can have severe and long-term negative impacts on the mental and emotional well-being of children. The deportation of children is also an issue that has economic and societal repercussions. It is the duty of the government to take adequate measures to address the issue of immigration and deportation of foreign children, without compromising the rights and well-being of children and their families.


To some people, the thought of child deportation is a horrific one, even children that are classified as illegal immigrants. In fact, approaching the issue of the deportation of children of illegal immigration is much different from that of adults who illegally immigrated into America.

Some children come from foreign countries on their own, such is a very common theme for children immigrating from Mexico. Some of these children are in their teens and will often attempt to migrate as a result of the requests of other family members.

Other children are brought illegally to the United States when they are young by their families. Statistically speaking, most illegal immigrants who come to the United States as children are under the age of six. The United States, then, will become the only home they know or remember. Their schools and friends will be in the United States and the child will become immersed in American culture. Whether or not the young child wished to come to the United States is not only irrelevant, but rarely considered in regards to that child’s deportation.

Due to this fact, child deportation from America is decidedly complex. While the United States should not be expected to be a home to foreign-born children without legal status, the moral imperative that compels policymakers to act on their behalf may leave them conflicted in regards to those children who cannot be saved by a green card petition.